Brooklyn Bowling Alleys

Hey everyone, welcome back to *Brooklyn Echoes*, the podcast that keeps the borough’s legends and memories alive. I’m your host, Robert Henriksen. In the swinging 1960s through the vibrant 1980s, bowling alleys in Brooklyn, New York, stood as bustling pillars of community life, blending sport, socializing, and a dash of underground excitement amid the borough’s evolving urban landscape. As post-war America embraced leisure activities, bowling surged in popularity, transforming from a niche pastime into a mainstream escape for working-class families, immigrants, and youth navigating the civil rights era, economic shifts, and cultural revolutions like disco and hip-hop. Brooklyn’s alleys, often tucked into neighborhoods like Bay Ridge, Sunset Park, Canarsie, and East New York, hosted league nights, birthday parties, school tournaments, and first dates, where the rhythmic clatter of pins and the scent of polished wood floors created unbreakable bonds. Yet, beneath the wholesome facade, many venues pulsed with “action bowling”—high-stakes gambling matches that drew hustlers, thugs, and con men wagering thousands from dusk till dawn, especially in the 1960s, when street money and shylocks enforced the games’ gritty rules. Figures like Ernie Schlegel, a brash West Side pro, and Brooklyn’s Richie Hornreich epitomized this era, turning alleys into arenas of risk and skill. By the 1970s, bowling peaked as a social unifier, drawing diverse crowds for tournaments and casual play, though rising costs began shuttering spots by the 1980s. Dozens of alleys dotted the borough, but a few rose to legendary status, fostering memories that endure even as many faded into history.

No alley embodied Brooklyn’s bowling heyday quite like Maple Lanes, a grand venue that opened its doors in 1960 on 60th Street in Bensonhurst. Boasting 48 gleaming lanes, it quickly became the borough’s cornerstone, drawing crowds for its restaurant serving Greek fare, vibrant leagues, and community events that spanned generations. In the 1960s and 1970s, it hosted school tournaments, late-night egg creams at the snack bar, and packed weekends where families and friends bonded over strikes and spares. Regulars recall it as the “best in Brooklyn,” a place where kids grew up learning the game and adults escaped daily grinds. By the 1980s, it remained a staple for pro-ams and casual play, but economic pressures led to its closure in the early 2000s, with the building eyed for condos—though gas pipes beneath halted redevelopment plans. Today, it lives in nostalgia, a symbol of the era’s communal spirit.

Another star was Gil Hodges Lanes, a sprawling spot at 2231 Ralph Avenue in Mill Basin that debuted in 1961 with an impressive 64 lanes—among the largest in the city. Owned by Brooklyn Dodgers and Mets legend Gil Hodges, a Hall of Fame first baseman, it blended sports fame with local pride, attracting families and leagues from across the borough. In the 1960s, it sponsored youth teams like Amity Little League, fostering the next generation of athletes. The 1970s saw it thrive as a community staple, hosting tournaments behind King’s Plaza mall and drawing diverse crowds for its welcoming vibe. By the 1980s, it remained a go-to for dates and outings, but like many, it eventually closed, leaving behind fond memories of Hodges’ personal touch. Tucked in a hard-to-reach inlet, its legacy endures through photos and stories of Brooklyn’s baseball-bowling crossover.

Sunset Park’s Melody Lanes captured the era’s retro charm, opening in 1958 but hitting its stride in the 1960s with 26 lanes that buzzed through the 1980s. Known for neon lights, live music, and an irony-free, borderline-seedy atmosphere, it drew a diverse crowd for inexpensive fun, arcade games, and glow bowling nights. In the 1970s, it hosted birthday parties, field trips, and leagues, with bartenders like Peter Napolitano becoming local legends for their wit. The 1980s kept the energy high, with regulars like snack bar manager Ms. Carr Falsetta overseeing the action since her teenage years. Unlike many that vanished, Melody Lanes survives today, a testament to Brooklyn’s enduring bowling spirit amid pandemics and change.

In East New York’s Cypress Hills, Hale Lanes on Hale Avenue and Fulton Street offered a gritty, longstanding escape, with roots in the 1940s but thriving through the 1960s-1980s. Featuring 10-24 lanes with steel pillars and overground ball returns, it was a neighborhood fixture for leagues and casual games from 1958-1965 and beyond, adjacent to spots like Lorenzo’s Pizzeria. Memories from locals highlight its role in daily life until it faded, possibly in the 1980s.

Canarsie’s Terminal Recreation Center (later Jersey Lynne Farms Bowling) at 8801 Foster Avenue debuted in 1942 with 12 lanes, evolving through the 1950s-1960s as a wood-paneled hub with billiards and fluorescent lights. By 1966, the lanes were removed for a discotheque conversion to Tempo City in 1968, a mob-tied spot featuring bands like The Chambers Brothers and The Illusion, before becoming Coconut Grove in the mid-1970s for events.

Other notables included Diplomat Lanes in Flatbush for its diverse leagues, Shell Lanes on Avenue X for its challenging play, and Rainbow Lanes in Sheepshead Bay, owned by pro Mark Roth. As the 1980s waned, many alleys closed amid rising expenses, but their legacy—of unity, competition, and simple joy—rolls on in Brooklyn’s collective memory.

If you like this podcast, Check out our new Brooklyn Echo’s Audio podcast at The Brooklyn Hall of Fame were we have been recording episodes to stream  at your favorite streaming services like Apple or Spotify.