Sheepshead Bay Fishing History

Hey everyone, welcome back to *Brooklyn Echoes*, the podcast that keeps the borough’s legends and memories alive. I’m your host, Robert Henriksen.

Sheepshead Bay, located in southern Brooklyn, has a long and storied history tied to fishing, evolving from a pre-colonial Native American hunting ground to a bustling maritime hub, and later facing challenges from urban development and industry decline. Named after the sheepshead fish (a porgy species with distinctive teeth), the area has been associated with angling and boating since indigenous times, when the Lenape people fished its waters. Below, I’ll outline the key historical phases, focusing on fishing practices and the iconic boats that defined the bay.

### Early History (Pre-Colonial to 19th Century)

The bay, originally a marshy inlet known as “the Cove,” was a secluded spot for fishing and farming as part of the town of Gravesend. Native Americans used it for sustenance fishing and hunting before European settlement. By the early 1800s, it remained a quiet fishing village, with small-scale operations targeting local species like sheepshead, flounder, and striped bass. In the 1840s, it began attracting summer vacationers, blending recreational angling with commercial efforts. A land boom in 1877 spurred real estate development, transforming it from a farmers’ and fishermen’s enclave into a more accessible resort area, though fishing remained central.

### Development and Peak Fishing Era (Early 20th Century to Mid-20th Century)

By the early 1900s, infrastructure improvements boosted the fishing industry. The channel was dredged by 1916, allowing larger fishing boats to dock directly in the bay instead of at nearby Canarsie, which facilitated commercial and charter operations. This era saw the rise of party boats—large vessels that carried groups of anglers offshore for day trips—and charter boats for private outings. The bay became synonymous with recreational fishing, drawing crowds for species like bluefish, fluke, tautog (blackfish), and striped bass.

Piers along Emmons Avenue were key, with the first nine dedicated to charter fishing boats and a fuel tender, while Pier 10 served excursion vessels. Bait barges supplied live bait, and the area gained fame for its seafood restaurants, evolving from a working waterfront to a cultural landmark. Historical accounts highlight a vibrant scene in the 1920s-1950s, with boats departing daily amid a backdrop of racetracks (like the nearby Sheepshead Bay Race Track, operational until 1910) and growing tourism.

### Iconic Boats and Captains

Sheepshead Bay’s fishing legacy is embodied in its fleet of boats, many of which were family-operated and became local legends. These included wooden-hulled party boats built for durability in the Atlantic’s rough waters, often converted from military or commercial vessels post-WWII. Notable examples from oral histories and memories include:

– **America**: A popular charter boat in the 1970s-1980s, known for bluefish runs.

– **Betty W**: Specialized in fluke and striped bass fishing; a staple for bottom fishing trips.

– **Dorothy B**: Another 1970s-1980s vessel, favored for its reliable captains and group outings.

– **Pilot**: Renowned for tautog (blackfish) expeditions, drawing dedicated anglers.

These boats, often 50-100 feet long, could carry 20-100 passengers and were piloted by experienced captains like those discussed in local podcasts, who navigated from the bay to offshore wrecks and reefs. Larger “yacht-sized” party boats like the **Pink Lady** and **The Atlantis** emerged in later decades, offering amenities for all-day adventures. The fleet peaked mid-century, with dozens moored along the piers, but many were retired or repurposed as pollution, overfishing, and regulations took a toll.

### Decline and Modern Legacy (Late 20th Century to Present)

By the 1970s-1980s, the fishing industry began fading due to urban encroachment, environmental issues (e.g., polluted waters from nearby landfills), and competition from other ports. Conflicts arose over waterfront space, with luxury yachts and restaurants displacing traditional boats. Today, a smaller fleet operates, focusing on charters and eco-tours, but the bay retains its fishing heritage through events, museums, and oral histories preserved by groups like the Brooklyn Fishing Club. For more, check resources like Urban Archive’s maritime timelines or local podcasts for firsthand captain stories. If you’re planning a visit, some historic piers still host boats, blending nostalgia with active fishing.

If you like this podcast, Check out our new Brooklyn Echo’s Audio podcast at The Brooklyn Hall of Fame were we have been recording episodes to stream  at your favorite streaming services like Apple or Spotify.